Priced under appraised AND assessed values! Discover a perfect blend of space, privacy & possibility on a stunning 1.73-acre tree-lined lot in the Town of Middleton. This 5-bed, 3.5-bath Colonial (custom-built by Keuler) offers timeless design & incredible potential to make it your own. Step into a dramatic great room w/soaring 16' ceilings, flanked by elegant formal sitting/dining spaces and a main-floor office w/french doors. Entertain in the walk-out lower level w/wet bar, gas fireplace & spacious guest suite or gym. Upstairs, four generously sized bedrooms include a primary suite w/walk-in closet & private bath. A 3-car garage, freshly stained deck, 7-person hot tub, and included UHP Ultimate Warranty complete this rare offering--just minutes from top-rated schools & West amenities.